For most drivers, I’d start with the Thule Pulse 2 L: its 16-cubic-foot hard shell and dual-side access make it a strong all-around choice for regular trips. The GarveeTech 12 Cu. Ft. box is a more compact hard-shell option, while the WEIZE heavy-duty basket bundle suits bulky loads when open-air access matters more than full enclosure. The main tradeoff is between the weather protection and security of a box, the low storage footprint of a soft bag, and the flexibility of a basket. Fit, roof-load limits, mounting style, and access to the vehicle’s hatch can matter as much as capacity. Read on for how all 15 roof cargo carriers compare and which type best fits your plans.
Get your wardrobe favorites delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Key Takeaways
- The Thule Pulse 2 L is my best overall pick for frequent use: it pairs a hard shell with dual-side access, though its 16-cubic-foot capacity is smaller than the largest soft bags.
- Soft bags lead on stated capacity: the FIVKLEMNZ 30-cubic-foot carrier offers much more volume than the hard-shell boxes, but a flexible bag needs careful packing and secure attachment.
- Baskets favor irregular cargo and quick access: WEIZE, CAMMOO, and MeeFar options provide open platforms, while the included bags and straps on several bundles add some weather protection.
- Size is not a substitute for vehicle fit: the two MeeFar baskets differ in footprint, and a larger carrier can create hatch-access, clearance, or roof-load problems.
- Hard shells, soft bags, and baskets solve different problems: the D SOLUTIONS, GarveeTech, Thule, and SportRack boxes enclose cargo; bags fold away; baskets keep tall or awkward items accessible.
| WEIZE Heavy-Duty Roof Cargo Basket with Waterproof Bag, Cargo Net, and Straps | ![]() | Best Basket-and-Bag Package | Basket dimensions: 64 × 39 × 5 inches | Load capacity: 200 pounds | Item weight: 46 pounds | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| GarveeTech Rooftop Cargo Box, Dual-Side Opening, 12 Cu. Ft., Black | ![]() | Best for Easy Side Access | Capacity: 12 cubic feet (340 L) | Maximum load: 165 pounds | Dimensions: 54.3 × 31.5 × 13.4 inches | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Asinking 15-Cubic-Foot Waterproof Rooftop Cargo Carrier Bag | ![]() | Best for Roof-Rack-Free Flexibility | Capacity: 15 cubic feet | Dimensions: 44 × 34 × 17 inches | Weight: 3.99 kg | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| D SOLUTIONS Hard-Shell Rooftop Cargo Carrier | ![]() | Best for Simple Hard-Shell Storage | Capacity: 11 cubic feet | Load capacity: 110 pounds | Dimensions: 53 × 34 × 15 inches | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| CAMMOO 64 x 39-Inch Roof Rack Basket with Removable Fairing and Adjustable Support Bars | ![]() | Best for Long, Varied Loads | Basket dimensions: 64 × 39 × 5 inches | Soft bag dimensions: 51 × 39 × 17 inches | Listed soft bag capacity: 20 cubic feet; kit contents also list 15 cubic feet | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| WEIZE Adjustable Steel Roof Cargo Basket with Waterproof Bag, Straps, and Net | ![]() | Best for Changing Cargo Loads | Material: Alloy steel | Adjustable sizes: 34.5 × 39 × 5 in, 49 × 39 × 5 in, or 64 × 39 × 5 in | Listed load capacity: 200 lbs; title also lists 150 lbs | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| MeeFar Roof Cargo Basket with Waterproof Bag, 65 x 39 x 6 Inches | ![]() | Best for Large Basket Loads | Material: Alloy steel | Dimensions: 65 × 39 × 6 in | Load capacity: 200 lbs, subject to vehicle roof limit | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Thule Pulse 2 L Roof-Mounted Cargo Box, 16 cu ft, Dual-Side Opening | ![]() | Best Hard-Shell Option | Model: Pulse 2 L | Capacity: 450 liters (16 cu ft) | Load capacity: 75 kg | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| WEIZE Universal Roof Rack Cargo Basket with Waterproof Bag and Cargo Net | ![]() | Best Adjustable Basket Value | Material: Tubular alloy steel | Assembled dimensions: 54 × 34 × 6 in | Adjustable dimensions: 35 × 34 × 6 in or 54 × 34 × 6 in | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| FIVKLEMNZ 30-Cubic-Foot Waterproof Soft Rooftop Cargo Carrier | ![]() | Best for Maximum Soft-Bag Capacity | Capacity: 30 cubic feet | Dimensions: 60 × 43 × 20 in in description; 60 × 60 × 20 in in item details | Material: 840D PVC; Oxford cloth also listed | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| FIVKLEMNZ 21-Cubic-Foot Waterproof Soft Rooftop Cargo Carrier | ![]() | Best for Weather Protection Without a Roof Rack | Capacity: 21 cubic feet | Dimensions: 52 × 40 × 17 inches | Material: 840D PVC; product details also list Oxford cloth | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Sailnovo 20-Cubic-Foot Rooftop Cargo Bag | ![]() | Best Foldable Soft-Bag Value | Capacity: 20 cubic feet | Dimensions: 51 × 39 × 17 inches | Material: 1000D Oxford cloth | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Asinking 21-Cubic-Foot Waterproof Rooftop Cargo Carrier Bag | ![]() | Best Fully Accessorized Waterproof Bag | Capacity: 21 cubic feet | Dimensions: 52 × 40 × 18 inches | Material: 840D PVC | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| SportRack Vista XL Rear-Opening Cargo Box, Black | ![]() | Best Hard-Shell Pick for Safer Roadside Access | Capacity: 18 cubic feet (510 L) | Material: UV-resistant ABS plastic | Opening: Rear | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| MeeFar Roof Rack Cargo Basket with Waterproof Bag, 51 x 36 x 5 Inches | ![]() | Best for Crossbar Owners Who Want Open-Top Flexibility | Basket dimensions: 51 × 36 × 5 inches | Material: Alloy steel with black epoxy coating | Load capacity: 200 pounds, subject to vehicle roof limit | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| roofcargo carrier | Material | Warranty | Dimensions | Capacity |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| WEIZE Heavy-Duty Roof Cargo Ba | Alloy steel | 1 year | — | — |
| GarveeTech Rooftop Cargo Box | ABS | — | 54.3 × 31.5 × 13.4 inches | 12 cubic feet (340 L) |
| Asinking 15-Cubic-Foot Waterpr | 840D PVC | 2 years | 44 × 34 × 17 inches | 15 cubic feet |
| D SOLUTIONS Hard-Shell Rooftop | ABS plastic | — | 53 × 34 × 15 inches | 11 cubic feet |
| CAMMOO 64 x 39-Inch Roof Rack | — | One year | — | — |
| WEIZE Adjustable Steel Roof Ca | Alloy steel | 1 year | — | — |
| MeeFar Roof Cargo Basket with | Alloy steel | — | 65 × 39 × 6 in | — |
| Thule Pulse 2 L Roof-Mounted C | ASA-ABS plastic | Limited lifetime | 81 × 17 × 37 in | 450 liters (16 cu ft) |
| WEIZE Universal Roof Rack Carg | Tubular alloy steel | — | — | — |
| FIVKLEMNZ 30-Cubic-Foot Waterp | 840D PVC; Oxford cloth also listed | 12 months | 60 × 43 × 20 in in description; 60 × 60 × 20 in in item details | 30 cubic feet |
| FIVKLEMNZ 21-Cubic-Foot Waterp | 840D PVC; product details also list Oxford cloth | 12 months | 52 × 40 × 17 inches | 21 cubic feet |
| Sailnovo 20-Cubic-Foot Rooftop | 1000D Oxford cloth | 1 year | 51 × 39 × 17 inches | 20 cubic feet |
| Asinking 21-Cubic-Foot Waterpr | 840D PVC | — | 52 × 40 × 18 inches | 21 cubic feet |
| SportRack Vista XL Rear-Openin | UV-resistant ABS plastic | 25 years | 62.5 × 39 × 19 inches | 18 cubic feet (510 L) |
| MeeFar Roof Rack Cargo Basket | Alloy steel with black epoxy coating | 60 days | — | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
WEIZE Heavy-Duty Roof Cargo Basket with Waterproof Bag, Cargo Net, and Straps
I’d choose the WEIZE Heavy-Duty basket for buyers who want an open rack and a weather-covering bag in one package. Its 64 × 39-inch platform and 200-pound stated capacity give it a sturdier cargo-carrying profile than the soft Asinking bag, while the included bag, net, and straps reduce the need to source basic securing gear separately. The powder-coated steel frame, side rails, bottom bars, and wind fairing add structure, though the open basket still exposes uncovered loads to the elements. At 46 pounds, it is also a heavier piece to lift and store than a soft carrier. I’d put it ahead of the CAMMOO when straightforward basket-and-bag use matters more than adjustable support bars for long cargo.
Pros:- Large 64 × 39-inch basket with a stated 200-pound load capacity
- Includes a waterproof bag, cargo net, and tie-down straps
- Powder-coated steel frame with side rails and bottom bars
- Wind fairing helps shield cargo from direct airflow
Cons:- At 46 pounds, it is relatively heavy to install and store
- U-bolt mounting requires crossbars within the specified thickness and width limits
- Open basket does not protect uncovered cargo from weather
Best for: Drivers with compatible crossbars who want a large steel basket, a supplied waterproof bag, and multiple ways to secure mixed luggage.
Not ideal for: Drivers whose crossbars exceed the stated size limits or who need a light carrier that is easy to lift onto the roof alone.
- Basket dimensions:64 × 39 × 5 inches
- Load capacity:200 pounds
- Item weight:46 pounds
- Material:Alloy steel
- Crossbar limits:Maximum thickness 1.35 inches; maximum width 4.6 inches
- Mounting:U-bolts to compatible crossbars
- Included components:Roof basket, waterproof bag, cargo net, and straps
- Warranty:1 year
Our verdict“Choose this WEIZE if you want a substantial steel basket with a bundled bag and securing accessories, and your crossbars meet its fit limits.”
GarveeTech Rooftop Cargo Box, Dual-Side Opening, 12 Cu. Ft., Black
The GarveeTech 12-cubic-foot box is the most convenient choice here for loading from whichever side of the vehicle is accessible. Its dual-sided opening is a practical distinction from the D SOLUTIONS box, which lists a key lock but not access from both sides. The ABS shell is described as waterproof and UV-resistant, giving luggage a more enclosed barrier than either the WEIZE or CAMMOO open baskets when their bags are not being used. Its 165-pound maximum load is higher than the D SOLUTIONS’ 110 pounds, but roof-rack fit still needs checking before purchase. The box also requires one side to be locked while the other is open, so access is flexible rather than simultaneous; buyers who need more volume may prefer a larger carrier.
Pros:- Dual-sided opening makes loading practical from either side of the vehicle
- Waterproof, UV-resistant ABS shell encloses luggage
- 165-pound maximum load exceeds the stated capacity of the D SOLUTIONS box
- Includes two keys and two straps
Cons:- Requires a roof rack, and compatibility should be checked before purchase
- One side must be locked while the other side is open
- 12 cubic feet offers less room than larger soft carriers such as the Asinking 15-cubic-foot bag
Best for: Travelers with a compatible roof rack who frequently load from either side of the car and want enclosed, weather-resistant storage.
Not ideal for: Drivers without a roof rack or those who need more than 12 cubic feet of storage or access to both sides at once.
- Capacity:12 cubic feet (340 L)
- Maximum load:165 pounds
- Dimensions:54.3 × 31.5 × 13.4 inches
- Item weight:39 pounds
- Material:ABS
- Water resistance:Waterproof; UV-resistant
- Opening:Dual-sided
- Included accessories:Two keys and two straps
Our verdict“Pick the GarveeTech if side-to-side access and an enclosed shell matter more than maximum cargo volume.”
Asinking 15-Cubic-Foot Waterproof Rooftop Cargo Carrier Bag
For drivers who do not have roof racks, the Asinking soft carrier is the most flexible fit in this group: it is specified for vehicles with or without roof racks and includes six door hooks. Its 15-cubic-foot capacity exceeds the GarveeTech hard box’s 12 cubic feet, and its 840D PVC fabric, reinforced seams, and waterproof zipper are intended to shield packed luggage. The tradeoff is the soft construction: it cannot provide the same rigid barrier as the GarveeTech or D SOLUTIONS ABS shells. Installation also depends on carefully routing and tightening the eight adjustable straps, rather than mounting a box to crossbars. The anti-slip mat and extra straps help with setup, but buyers who want a fixed, rigid carrier should choose a hard-shell option instead.
Pros:- 15-cubic-foot capacity provides more stated volume than the GarveeTech hard box
- Fits vehicles with or without roof racks
- Waterproof 840D PVC fabric, zipper, and reinforced seams
- Includes an anti-slip mat, six door hooks, extra straps, and a luggage lock
Cons:- Soft construction offers less rigid protection than ABS boxes such as the D SOLUTIONS
- Straps and door hooks require careful securing during installation
- The fit and stability depend on the vehicle and how the bag is fastened
Best for: Drivers without roof racks who need roomy, weather-resistant soft storage and are willing to secure it with straps and door hooks.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking rigid protection, quick hard-box mounting, or a carrier that does not require strap adjustment.
- Capacity:15 cubic feet
- Dimensions:44 × 34 × 17 inches
- Weight:3.99 kg
- Material:840D PVC
- Water resistance:Waterproof
- Fit:Vehicles with or without roof racks
- Straps:8 adjustable straps
- Included components:Storage bag, anti-slip mat, 6 door hooks, 2 extra straps, and luggage lock
- Warranty:2 years
Our verdict“Choose the Asinking bag if roof-rack-free compatibility and soft, high-volume storage matter more than a rigid shell.”
D SOLUTIONS Hard-Shell Rooftop Cargo Carrier
The D SOLUTIONS hard-shell box suits buyers who want enclosed, waterproof storage without paying for features they may not use, such as the GarveeTech’s dual-sided opening. Its 11-cubic-foot ABS shell is smaller than that 12-cubic-foot box and substantially below the Asinking bag’s 15 cubic feet, so I’d favor it for a more contained load rather than bulky family luggage. A key lock and included mounting brackets and hardware make the setup package clear, but the carrier still requires crossbars. Its 50.3-pound weight is the heaviest listed among these five products, making roof installation and off-roof storage less convenient. The 110-pound load limit is also lower than the GarveeTech’s, so heavy cargo may point elsewhere.
Pros:- Waterproof ABS shell encloses cargo against weather
- Includes a pair of keys, four mounting brackets, and mounting hardware
- Key lock adds a locking point for stored cargo
- Compact 11-cubic-foot capacity suits more contained loads
Cons:- Requires vehicle crossbars
- 50.3-pound item weight makes installation and storage more demanding
- 110-pound load capacity is lower than the GarveeTech box’s stated limit
Best for: Crossbar-equipped drivers who want a basic waterproof ABS box with a key lock and included mounting hardware.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need high capacity, a higher stated load limit, dual-side access, or a lighter box to handle during installation.
- Capacity:11 cubic feet
- Load capacity:110 pounds
- Dimensions:53 × 34 × 15 inches
- Item weight:50.3 pounds
- Material:ABS plastic
- Water resistance:Waterproof
- Mounting:Roof mount; fits vehicles with crossbars
- Included components:Cargo box, pair of keys, 4 mounting brackets, and mounting hardware
Our verdict“Choose the D SOLUTIONS if you want a straightforward locked hard box and can accept its lower capacity and heavier handling.”
CAMMOO 64 x 39-Inch Roof Rack Basket with Removable Fairing and Adjustable Support Bars
The CAMMOO basket is the most adaptable pick here for cargo that changes from trip to trip. Its removable fairing and seven-position support bars let owners configure the rack for ordinary luggage or longer items such as kayaks and surfboards; that flexibility sets it apart from the WEIZE basket, which is presented as a more straightforward fixed-platform package. CAMMOO also includes a waterproof soft bag, net, straps, and combination locks, although the listed bag capacity conflicts: one detail says 20 cubic feet, while kit contents say 15. I would verify that figure before buying. Fit is another limitation: it calls for raised side rails and compatible adjustable crossbars, and it does not fit round bars. This is a specialist choice, not the easiest universal setup.
Pros:- Removable fairing and adjustable support bars accommodate different cargo shapes
- Seven support-bar positions offer options for organizing or supporting loads
- Includes waterproof soft bag, cargo net, straps, and combination locks
- Large 64 × 39-inch basket footprint
Cons:- Requires raised side rails and compatible adjustable crossbars; round bars are excluded
- Soft-bag capacity is inconsistent in the product details, listed as both 20 and 15 cubic feet
- Crossbar spacing and dimensions need checking before purchase
Best for: Outdoor travelers with raised side rails who alternate between enclosed luggage and longer gear such as kayaks or surfboards.
Not ideal for: Drivers with round bars, no raised side rails, or a need for a clearly specified bag capacity and simple universal fit.
- Basket dimensions:64 × 39 × 5 inches
- Soft bag dimensions:51 × 39 × 17 inches
- Listed soft bag capacity:20 cubic feet; kit contents also list 15 cubic feet
- Support bar positions:7
- Bag material:600 g 840D laminated PVC mesh
- Crossbar compatibility:Adjustable crossbars; not round bars
- Crossbar fit limits:Thickness 3/4–1 5/8 inches; maximum interior width 6 1/8 inches; center-to-center spacing 7–46 inches
- Included components:Roof basket, waterproof soft bag with pouch, cargo net with 12 hooks, 2 combination locks, ratchet strap, and cam buckle strap
- Warranty:One year
Our verdict“Choose the CAMMOO if you carry changing or long cargo and have the specified rail and crossbar setup, but confirm the bag capacity first.”
WEIZE Adjustable Steel Roof Cargo Basket with Waterproof Bag, Straps, and Net
The three-length adjustment is the main reason I’d choose this WEIZE over the fixed-size MeeFar 65 x 39-inch basket: it can shorten for a smaller load and extend when bulky gear needs more room. The package also includes a waterproof bag, net, and two straps, so buyers get several ways to secure different shapes of cargo. Its listed 200-pound capacity is substantial, but the product title also cites 150 pounds; I’d verify the applicable limit before loading it, and follow the vehicle’s lower roof limit if that applies. At 47 pounds, it is no lightweight installation, and the maker recommends extra rustproofing despite the powder-coated finish. This makes the most sense for owners who value adjustable basket length over a simpler, fixed setup.
Pros:- Three length settings adapt the basket to changing cargo and vehicle needs.
- Includes a waterproof cargo bag, cargo net, and two 12-foot tie-down straps.
- Tubular alloy steel construction has a powder-coated finish.
- Listed as a universal fit for cars and SUVs.
Cons:- Capacity is inconsistent across the listing: the title says 150 pounds while product details say 200 pounds.
- At 47 pounds, mounting and storage may take more effort than with a soft carrier.
- The description recommends additional rustproofing despite the corrosion-resistant coating.
Best for: Drivers carrying loads that vary between trips and who want a basket that can be shortened or extended, plus included cargo-covering accessories.
Not ideal for: Shoppers who need a light, quick-to-lift rack or a clearly consistent published load limit; the basket weighs 47 pounds and its title and details differ on capacity.
- Material:Alloy steel
- Adjustable sizes:34.5 × 39 × 5 in, 49 × 39 × 5 in, or 64 × 39 × 5 in
- Listed load capacity:200 lbs; title also lists 150 lbs
- Item weight:47 lbs
- Mounting:Roof mount
- Fit:Universal
- Included components:Cargo net, two 12 ft tie-down straps, waterproof cargo bag, roof basket, mounting hardware
- Warranty:1 year
Our verdict“Choose this WEIZE if adjustable basket length and bundled cargo restraints matter more than low weight or a consistent capacity listing.”
MeeFar Roof Cargo Basket with Waterproof Bag, 65 x 39 x 6 Inches
This MeeFar is the pick for buyers who want a wide, full-length steel basket with a substantial bag included. Its 65 x 39-inch frame gives it more listed length than the WEIZE Universal Roof Rack Cargo Basket, while a wind shield helps deflect airflow around cargo. The package also includes a 20-cubic-foot waterproof bag, net, ratchet straps, and a combination lock, making it better equipped out of the box than a bare basket. The tradeoff is fit and installation: it mounts to crossbars with four U-bolts, so it is not a rack-free solution like the FIVKLEMNZ soft carrier. Assembly can be shortened to 45 inches, but that still leaves crossbar compatibility and vehicle roof limits to check before loading.
Pros:- Large 65 x 39-inch basket provides room for bulky cargo.
- Includes a 20-cubic-foot waterproof bag, net with hooks, ratchet straps, and combination lock.
- Wind shield helps protect cargo from direct airflow.
- Assembly can be shortened to 45 inches.
Cons:- Requires compatible crossbars and installation with four U-bolts.
- The vehicle’s roof weight limit may be lower than the basket’s listed 200-pound capacity.
- Large basket dimensions can be more rack than needed for smaller loads or vehicles.
Best for: SUV and wagon owners with compatible crossbars who need a large basket and an included high-volume cargo bag for bulky trip gear.
Not ideal for: Drivers without crossbars, or anyone whose vehicle roof limit is too low for a loaded basket; its 200-pound rack rating does not override the vehicle limit.
- Material:Alloy steel
- Dimensions:65 × 39 × 6 in
- Load capacity:200 lbs, subject to vehicle roof limit
- Bag capacity:20 cubic feet
- Mounting:Roof mount to crossbars with four U-bolts
- Fit:Universal
- Included accessories:Waterproof bag, cargo net with hooks, ratchet straps, combination lock
- Adjustability:Can be shortened to 45 in
Our verdict“Pick the MeeFar when a large basket and bundled 20-cubic-foot bag suit your trips and your vehicle already has compatible crossbars.”
Thule Pulse 2 L Roof-Mounted Cargo Box, 16 cu ft, Dual-Side Opening
Unlike the open baskets from WEIZE and MeeFar, the Thule Pulse 2 L is a hard-shell box that encloses luggage and keeps it out of sight. Its 16-cubic-foot capacity is smaller than the FIVKLEMNZ 30-cubic-foot soft carrier, but the dual-side opening makes access easier when parking or roof-bar placement blocks one side. Tool-free mounting and a torque indicator help guide attachment without a separate tool, while forward positioning is intended to preserve trunk access. There is a key caveat: the supplied specifications list it as not water resistant, so I would not choose it for cargo that needs protection from rain. Its 75 kg load rating also needs to be read alongside the vehicle and roof-system limits.
Pros:- Rigid shell encloses and conceals luggage, unlike an open basket.
- Dual-side opening offers access from either side of the vehicle.
- Tool-free attachment system includes a torque indicator.
- Forward positioning is designed to preserve trunk access.
Cons:- Listed as not water resistant, making it a poor fit for cargo requiring rain protection.
- At 16 cubic feet, it has less stated capacity than the FIVKLEMNZ 30-cubic-foot carrier.
- The 75 kg load rating must be checked against vehicle and roof-system limits.
Best for: Drivers who prefer an enclosed, rigid box for luggage and want access from either side, with a tool-free mounting system.
Not ideal for: Travelers carrying rain-sensitive items or those who need more space than 16 cubic feet; the listing says it is not water resistant, and the FIVKLEMNZ soft carrier offers greater stated volume.
- Model:Pulse 2 L
- Capacity:450 liters (16 cu ft)
- Load capacity:75 kg
- Dimensions:81 × 17 × 37 in
- Material:ASA-ABS plastic
- Opening:Dual-side
- Water resistance:Not water resistant
- Warranty:Limited lifetime
Our verdict“Choose this Thule for enclosed luggage and convenient two-sided access, but skip it if weather protection or maximum volume is your priority.”
WEIZE Universal Roof Rack Cargo Basket with Waterproof Bag and Cargo Net
This WEIZE offers a simpler two-length adjustment than the three-setting WEIZE Adjustable Steel Roof Cargo Basket, which suits buyers who want a choice of compact or extended basket without as many configuration options. Its 54 x 34-inch assembled frame is also narrower than the MeeFar 65 x 39-inch basket, so it may be easier to match to a more modest load. A waterproof bag, net, and ratchet straps come in the package, and the wind shield helps deflect airflow. The tradeoff is that this is still a 41-pound steel rack that needs compatible crossbars and four U-bolts; the soft FIVKLEMNZ carrier can mount without roof racks. I’d choose this for a crossbar-equipped SUV, MPV, or truck when a steel platform is preferable to a soft bag.
Pros:- Adjusts between 35 and 54 inches to suit different cargo loads.
- Includes a waterproof bag, cargo net with hooks, and ratchet straps.
- Wind shield helps deflect airflow around cargo.
- Epoxy powder coating is described as rust resistant.
Cons:- Requires compatible vehicle crossbars and four U-bolts for mounting.
- The 41-pound rack is heavier to lift and store than a soft cargo carrier.
- Its 54 × 34-inch assembled size is smaller than the MeeFar 65 × 39-inch basket for especially bulky loads.
Best for: SUV, MPV, and pickup owners with compatible crossbars who want an adjustable steel basket and included ways to cover and secure cargo.
Not ideal for: Drivers without crossbars or anyone seeking a light, rack-free carrier; this basket weighs 41 pounds and mounts with four U-bolts.
- Material:Tubular alloy steel
- Assembled dimensions:54 × 34 × 6 in
- Adjustable dimensions:35 × 34 × 6 in or 54 × 34 × 6 in
- Load capacity:200 lbs
- Mounting:Roof mount with four universal U-bolts
- Compatible vehicles:SUV, MPV, truck
- Included accessories:Waterproof bag, cargo net with hooks, ratchet straps
- Item weight:41 lbs
Our verdict“Choose this WEIZE if you have crossbars and want a mid-size adjustable steel basket with a waterproof bag and restraints included.”
FIVKLEMNZ 30-Cubic-Foot Waterproof Soft Rooftop Cargo Carrier
For buyers focused on volume rather than a rigid platform, this FIVKLEMNZ provides 30 cubic feet of waterproof soft storage—nearly twice the Thule Pulse 2 L’s stated 16 cubic feet. Its rack-free fit claim is a meaningful difference from both WEIZE baskets, which require crossbars; straps and six door hooks give owners several attachment options, and the included anti-slip mat adds a buffer between bag and vehicle roof. Welded seams and a double-layer cover are intended to keep contents dry. The main reservation is a conflicting dimension listing: the description says 60 x 43 x 20 inches, while item details say 60 x 60 x 20 inches. I’d verify fit and attachment guidance for the vehicle before relying on the advertised capacity.
Pros:- 30-cubic-foot capacity exceeds the Thule Pulse 2 L’s stated 16 cubic feet.
- Waterproof construction includes welded seams and a double-layer cover.
- Designed for vehicles with or without roof racks.
- Includes reinforced straps, six door hooks, anti-slip mat, luggage lock, and storage bag.
Cons:- Dimensions conflict between the description and item details: 60 × 43 × 20 in versus 60 × 60 × 20 in.
- Soft strap mounting does not provide the rigid structure of a hard-shell cargo box.
- Fit and attachment setup require care because the carrier can be mounted to vehicles without roof racks.
Best for: Travelers needing high-volume soft storage who lack roof racks and want a carrier supplied with straps, door hooks, and an anti-slip mat.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need confirmed dimensions before purchase or prefer a rigid, securely enclosed box; the listed measurements conflict, and this is a soft strap-mounted bag.
- Capacity:30 cubic feet
- Dimensions:60 × 43 × 20 in in description; 60 × 60 × 20 in in item details
- Material:840D PVC; Oxford cloth also listed
- Water resistance:Waterproof
- Mounting:Strap mount
- Fit:Universal; designed for vehicles with or without roof racks
- Included accessories:Anti-slip mat, reinforced straps, six door hooks, luggage lock, storage bag
- Weight:5.44 kg
- Warranty:12 months
Our verdict“Choose the FIVKLEMNZ if you need generous waterproof soft storage without crossbars and can confirm its dimensions for your vehicle.”
FIVKLEMNZ 21-Cubic-Foot Waterproof Soft Rooftop Cargo Carrier
The FIVKLEMNZ makes sense for drivers who want 21 cubic feet of soft-sided storage and need a carrier that can mount with or without roof racks. Its 840D PVC construction, welded seams, and double-layer cover are aimed at keeping travel gear dry in rain or snow, while the included mat, straps, and six door hooks give buyers more of the setup in one package. Compared with the Sailnovo 20-Cubic-Foot Rooftop Cargo Bag, it offers slightly more stated capacity and a stronger waterproofing claim; Sailnovo instead specifies a water-resistant coating and lighter listed weight. The tradeoff is shared by soft bags generally: luggage gets less impact protection than in the SportRack Vista XL hard box. Material details also conflict, listing both PVC and Oxford cloth, so I would verify the construction before relying on that distinction.
Pros:- 21-cubic-foot capacity for bulky trip luggage
- Waterproof cover and welded seams are designed to limit water entry
- Fits vehicles with or without roof racks
- Includes anti-slip mat, straps, six door hooks, lock, and storage bag
Cons:- Soft construction offers less impact protection than a hard-shell box
- Product information lists both 840D PVC and Oxford cloth
- Load stability depends on careful packing and strap setup
Best for: Drivers without roof racks who want a high-capacity soft carrier with included mounting accessories and rain-focused protection.
Not ideal for: Buyers carrying fragile or valuable gear that needs a rigid shell, or anyone who wants unambiguous material specifications.
- Capacity:21 cubic feet
- Dimensions:52 × 40 × 17 inches
- Material:840D PVC; product details also list Oxford cloth
- Water resistance:Waterproof
- Vehicle fit:Universal; with or without roof rack
- Included accessories:Anti-slip mat, reinforced straps, six door hooks, luggage lock, storage bag
- Weight:4.68 kg
- Warranty:12 months
Our verdict“Choose this FIVKLEMNZ if you need rack-free mounting and a large, rain-focused soft bag; skip it if rigid protection or precise material details matter more.”
Sailnovo 20-Cubic-Foot Rooftop Cargo Bag
The Sailnovo is a practical pick for drivers who want 20 cubic feet of foldable storage without moving to a rigid box. Its 1000D Oxford cloth, reinforced seams, and heavy-duty zippers provide a rugged fabric build, while the supplied straps and door hooks support several roof setups. Against the FIVKLEMNZ 21-Cubic-Foot Waterproof Soft Rooftop Cargo Carrier, Sailnovo gives up one cubic foot and describes its protection as water-resistant rather than waterproof; in return, it has a clearly specified Oxford-cloth construction and a compact-storage format. The installation caveats matter: door hooks need an exposed metal door frame, and the bag is not recommended over a sunroof unless used with a roof basket. I’d also pack it so the top stays supported, since underfilling can allow water to pool.
Pros:- 20-cubic-foot capacity suits bulky travel gear
- Foldable design takes less storage space when not in use
- 1000D Oxford cloth with reinforced seams and heavy-duty zippers
- Includes tie-down straps, six door hooks, extra luggage straps, and storage bag
Cons:- Water-resistant coating is a less definitive weather claim than the waterproof soft bags in this lineup
- Door hooks require an exposed metal door frame
- Needs a sufficiently full, well-shaped load to reduce water pooling
Best for: Occasional road-trippers who want a foldable, high-capacity bag and have a compatible door-frame or roof-basket setup.
Not ideal for: Drivers with sunroofs who plan to mount it without a roof basket, or travelers who need waterproof rather than water-resistant protection.
- Capacity:20 cubic feet
- Dimensions:51 × 39 × 17 inches
- Material:1000D Oxford cloth
- Water resistance:Water-resistant coating
- Weight:8.3 pounds
- Compatibility:Most roofs with crossbars, side rails, baskets, or no rack
- Included components:Two extra luggage straps, six extra door hooks, storage bag, manual
- Warranty:1 year
Our verdict“Pick the Sailnovo for foldable capacity and a specified Oxford-cloth build, provided its mounting and weather limitations fit your vehicle and trips.”
Asinking 21-Cubic-Foot Waterproof Rooftop Cargo Carrier Bag
Asinking pairs 21 cubic feet of capacity with a clearly stated 840D PVC shell, reinforced seams, and a waterproof zipper flap. That makes it a strong fit for travelers who prefer a soft bag but want weather-focused details and a ready-to-mount accessory set. Compared with the FIVKLEMNZ 21-Cubic-Foot Waterproof Soft Rooftop Cargo Carrier, Asinking specifies PVC consistently and includes padded door hooks plus two extra straps; FIVKLEMNZ lists a double-layer cover but has conflicting material information. Neither can match the SportRack Vista XL for rigid protection, and a soft bag still needs careful loading and tensioning to stay stable at highway speeds. I’d choose Asinking for its clearer material description and kit, not for a set-and-forget fit: secure the load evenly and recheck the straps during travel.
Pros:- 21-cubic-foot capacity for substantial luggage loads
- 840D PVC, reinforced seams, and waterproof zipper flap
- Compatible with vehicles with or without roof racks
- Includes anti-slip mat, six padded hooks, two extra straps, lock, and storage bag
Cons:- Soft-shell construction provides less impact protection than a rigid cargo box
- Careful loading and strap tension are needed for a stable fit
- A soft carrier can be less convenient to access and secure than a hard box
Best for: Road-trippers seeking a large waterproof soft carrier with padded hooks and extra securing straps, whether or not their vehicle has roof racks.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need hard-shell impact protection or want a carrier that does not require attention to packing and strap tension.
- Capacity:21 cubic feet
- Dimensions:52 × 40 × 18 inches
- Material:840D PVC
- Water resistance:Waterproof
- Mounting and fit:Rooftop; compatible with vehicles with or without roof racks
- Closure:Zipper with waterproof flap
- Included accessories:Anti-slip mat, six padded door hooks, storage bag, two extra straps, luggage lock
- Weight:4.24 kg
Our verdict“Choose Asinking if you want a large waterproof soft bag with a detailed accessory kit, and are prepared to secure and monitor it carefully.”
SportRack Vista XL Rear-Opening Cargo Box, Black
The SportRack Vista XL is the lineup’s rigid, rear-opening alternative to soft carriers such as the Asinking 21-Cubic-Foot Waterproof Rooftop Cargo Carrier Bag. Its 18-cubic-foot capacity is smaller, but the UV-resistant ABS shell gives cargo a sturdier enclosure, and the rear opening keeps loading and unloading on the side away from passing traffic. Tool-free mounting hardware and a lock add convenience, though buyers still need to match the box to their crossbar spacing and roof rack. Its 100-pound maximum load can also limit what goes inside, regardless of available volume. Compared with the soft bags, it is less adaptable to vehicles without crossbars and takes more space to store when removed. This is the better fit for rack-equipped drivers who prioritize a firm enclosure and rear access over maximum capacity.
Pros:- Rigid UV-resistant ABS shell offers more structure than the soft bags
- Rear opening keeps access away from roadside traffic
- Tool-free mounting hardware simplifies installation and removal
- Includes a lock and has a stated 25-year warranty
Cons:- Requires compatible crossbars and specified crossbar spacing
- 100-pound maximum load may constrain dense cargo
- Less capacity than the 20- and 21-cubic-foot soft carriers
Best for: Drivers with compatible crossbars who want a rigid cargo enclosure and prefer loading from the rear, away from roadside traffic.
Not ideal for: Drivers without compatible roof racks, those needing more than 18 cubic feet, or buyers whose cargo could exceed the 100-pound limit.
- Capacity:18 cubic feet (510 L)
- Material:UV-resistant ABS plastic
- Opening:Rear
- Dimensions:62.5 × 39 × 19 inches
- Maximum weight capacity:100 pounds (45 kg)
- Crossbar spacing:23 5/8–29 3/4 inches (60–75.5 cm)
- Compatibility:SportRack, square, round, and most factory roof racks
- Warranty:25 years
Our verdict“Choose the Vista XL if your rack fits and you value a rigid shell with rear access more than maximum storage volume.”
MeeFar Roof Rack Cargo Basket with Waterproof Bag, 51 x 36 x 5 Inches
MeeFar takes a different approach from the enclosed bags and box: its steel basket carries an included 15-cubic-foot waterproof bag, plus a cargo net and ratchet straps for securing other items. The open basket can suit awkward loads that do not fit neatly inside a soft carrier, while the epoxy-coated steel frame provides a firm platform. Its stated 200-pound capacity is subject to the vehicle roof’s lower weight limit, so the vehicle—not just the basket—sets the practical ceiling. Compared with the SportRack Vista XL, MeeFar offers open-load flexibility and a higher stated capacity, but it requires crossbars and does not enclose cargo in a rigid shell. It also has less integrated weather protection than a dedicated waterproof bag unless luggage is placed inside the included bag. I’d reserve it for rack-equipped vehicles and mixed cargo needs.
Pros:- Steel basket supports varied shapes of cargo beyond a single enclosed bag
- Includes a 15-cubic-foot waterproof bag, cargo net, and ratchet straps
- Epoxy-coated tubular steel construction
- Stated 200-pound capacity, subject to the vehicle roof limit
Cons:- Requires vehicle crossbars
- Usable load may be restricted by the vehicle’s roof weight limit
- Open basket does not provide the integrated enclosure of a hard-shell box
Best for: Crossbar-equipped drivers who carry a mix of bagged luggage and bulky items and want a basket with tie-down accessories.
Not ideal for: Drivers without crossbars, owners with a low roof weight limit, or travelers who want a fully enclosed hard-shell carrier.
- Basket dimensions:51 × 36 × 5 inches
- Material:Alloy steel with black epoxy coating
- Load capacity:200 pounds, subject to vehicle roof limit
- Mounting:Roof mount; requires crossbars
- Fit:Universal for vehicles with crossbars
- Included bag capacity:15 cubic feet
- Included accessories:Cargo net with hooks, ratchet straps, combination lock
- Warranty:60 days
Our verdict“Pick MeeFar if you already have crossbars and want basket flexibility with an included waterproof bag, but check your vehicle’s roof limit first.”

How We Picked
I compared these 15 roof cargo carriers by the factors that shape a real purchase: cargo enclosure, stated capacity or dimensions, loading access, mounting approach, versatility, and likely storage demands when the carrier is off the vehicle. The lineup spans hard-shell boxes, soft bags, and open baskets, so I judged each type against its intended use rather than treating volume alone as a measure of quality. A larger stated capacity can help on family trips, but it does not outweigh a poor match for the vehicle’s roof or the owner’s storage needs.
My ranking gives priority to useful everyday balance, then to more specialized strengths such as compact dimensions, large soft-bag capacity, or an open basket format. Hard-shell models rank well for enclosed storage and repeated use; soft carriers earn consideration for flexible storage and generous stated volume, with more attention to packing and attachment; baskets suit cargo that benefits from an open platform but bring exposure to weather. Product names and listed features inform these distinctions, while compatibility, roof-load limits, and installation details should be checked against the vehicle and the manufacturer’s instructions before buying.
| roofcargo carrier | Water resistance |
|---|---|
| WEIZE Heavy-Duty Roof Cargo Ba | — |
| GarveeTech Rooftop Cargo Box | Waterproof; UV-resistant |
| Asinking 15-Cubic-Foot Waterpr | Waterproof |
| D SOLUTIONS Hard-Shell Rooftop | Waterproof |
| CAMMOO 64 x 39-Inch Roof Rack | — |
| WEIZE Adjustable Steel Roof Ca | — |
| MeeFar Roof Cargo Basket with | — |
| Thule Pulse 2 L Roof-Mounted C | Not water resistant |
| WEIZE Universal Roof Rack Carg | — |
| FIVKLEMNZ 30-Cubic-Foot Waterp | Waterproof |
| FIVKLEMNZ 21-Cubic-Foot Waterp | Waterproof |
| Sailnovo 20-Cubic-Foot Rooftop | Water-resistant coating |
| Asinking 21-Cubic-Foot Waterpr | Waterproof |
| SportRack Vista XL Rear-Openin | — |
| MeeFar Roof Rack Cargo Basket | — |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Roofcargo Carriers
Before choosing among these roof cargo carriers, I’d match the carrier to both the vehicle and the kinds of loads you actually take. The right decision is rarely just the largest listed capacity: roof limits, access, weather, parking clearance, and storage between trips can change which format makes sense.
Choose the carrier format around your cargo
A hard-shell box keeps belongings enclosed and is a natural fit for luggage or camping gear that should stay out of sight. A soft bag can provide high stated capacity while folding down for storage, but its flexible shape calls for thoughtful packing and firm attachment. An open basket is better suited to irregular, bulky items that do not fit neatly inside a box. Do not assume a waterproof bag included with a basket turns the whole setup into a sealed cargo box. Think about what you carry most often, not only the unusual load you might haul once.
Check roof limits and attachment compatibility
Start with the vehicle manual’s maximum roof load, including the carrier, crossbars, and cargo; the carrier’s own capacity does not raise the vehicle’s limit. Then confirm whether your car has compatible crossbars or needs a separate rack, since a product described as universal may still have fit conditions. Compare attachment points with your bar spacing and shape before ordering. Roof weight can also affect handling, especially when cargo is heavy or unevenly distributed. Keep heavy items low and spread their weight across the permitted area rather than loading one end of the carrier.
Treat capacity as a planning number, not a promise
Listed volume gives a rough comparison, but a bag’s flexible walls and a box’s fixed shape use space differently. A 30-cubic-foot soft carrier may hold more than a compact hard box on paper, yet bulky or rigid objects can be difficult to arrange inside it. Check dimensions as well as capacity, then compare them with your luggage and vehicle roof. Avoid packing a carrier so full that closures or straps are under strain. Leave room to secure the load properly, and follow the maker’s limits even if the remaining space looks usable.
Plan for hatch access, clearance, and driving
A long carrier can interfere with a rear hatch, while a wide basket or box can affect access to other roof equipment. Before a trip, confirm the carrier’s position allows the hatch to open and does not obstruct antennas, sunroofs, or other fittings. Measure total vehicle height with the loaded carrier for garages, parking structures, and low branches. Roof cargo adds wind exposure and can alter noise and fuel use, so a tall, bulky load may feel different from a lightly packed box. Secure every strap and check the load again after driving a short distance.
Balance weather protection, security, and storage
Hard shells provide a rigid enclosure, but buyers should verify the opening and locking details for the specific model rather than assuming every box offers the same security. Soft bags can be folded away when not in use, a useful advantage for drivers with limited garage space, but they demand careful closure and attachment. Baskets make loading simple and can accommodate awkward shapes, though exposed cargo needs its own weather protection. For any format, inspect seams, latches, straps, and mounting hardware periodically. If the carrier will stay on the vehicle between trips, factor in its height, upkeep, and exposure to the elements.
Know when a more expensive format earns its place
Paying more can make sense when you need frequent access, enclosed storage, or a rigid carrier that suits repeated travel. Occasional users may get more practical value from a foldable bag or a basket bundle with included tie-down accessories, provided the fit and load limits work. Extra volume is less useful if it forces you to exceed the roof rating or makes everyday parking difficult. Compare what is included, such as a bag, net, straps, or support bars, and check whether those pieces match your cargo needs. A careful fit check can prevent spending on capacity you cannot safely or comfortably use.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I choose a hard-shell box, soft bag, or cargo basket?
I’d choose by cargo type and how often the carrier will be used. A hard-shell box is suited to enclosed luggage storage and repeated trips, while a soft bag can offer generous volume and pack away more easily. A basket is useful for tall or oddly shaped items that are awkward to fit inside a box, but cargo is more exposed unless separately covered. Included waterproof bags on some baskets add flexibility, though they do not make the basket itself an enclosed shell. If security and weather protection lead your priorities, compare hard boxes first; if storage space at home is tight, look closely at soft carriers.
How can I tell whether a roof cargo carrier will fit my car?
Check the carrier’s mounting requirements against the crossbars already on your vehicle, including bar spacing, shape, and usable roof area. Read the vehicle manual for the permitted roof load and count the rack and carrier weight along with the cargo. Compare the carrier’s length and width with roof measurements, and check whether the rear hatch can still open. Do not rely on the word “universal” without confirming the actual fit instructions. If any measurement or load limit is unclear, ask the vehicle or carrier maker before driving with it installed.
Is a 30-cubic-foot soft carrier a better choice than a smaller roof box?
Not automatically: stated volume is only one part of the decision. A 30-cubic-foot bag offers generous listed space, but flexible sides can make packing rigid items harder and require careful attachment. A smaller hard box has a fixed shape and enclosed construction that may be easier for regular luggage use. Compare the carrier’s dimensions with the items you plan to bring, then check your vehicle’s roof limit and available roof area. Choose the larger bag only if its fit, load method, and storage advantages suit your trips.
Can I use a cargo basket in rain without a separate cover?
An open basket does not enclose cargo, so belongings need appropriate weather protection. Some baskets in this roundup come with a waterproof cargo bag, but buyers should check exactly what is included and follow its closure and attachment instructions. A bag can add protection, yet it is not the same as a rigid shell, and correct packing and secure fastening still matter. For sensitive gear or prolonged wet conditions, compare an enclosed box or a purpose-built bag rather than assuming the basket alone will protect everything. Keep the load within the product’s stated limits.
What should I check before driving with a loaded roof carrier?
Confirm the combined weight of the rack, carrier, and cargo stays within the vehicle’s roof-load limit, and distribute the load evenly. Check that every mount, strap, and closure is secure, with no loose ends or cargo able to shift. Verify hatch access and measure the vehicle’s new overall height for garages and other low-clearance routes. Follow the carrier maker’s driving instructions, since speed and use guidance can vary by product. After a short initial drive, stop somewhere safe and recheck the attachments before continuing.
Conclusion
For an all-around enclosed option, I’d choose the Thule Pulse 2 L; its dual-side opening and 16-cubic-foot capacity make it my best overall pick for regular trips. For value-minded buyers who want a bundle, the WEIZE Heavy-Duty Roof Cargo Basket combines an open platform with a waterproof bag, net, and straps, though it is less enclosed than a hard box. The Thule is also my best premium recommendation in this lineup, while the straightforward format of the GarveeTech 12 Cu. Ft. box makes it a sensible starting point for buyers who want a compact hard-shell carrier. For maximum stated soft-carrier volume, compare the FIVKLEMNZ 30-cubic-foot bag; for bulky gear and open access, look at the larger CAMMOO or MeeFar baskets. Before deciding, match dimensions and mounts to your roof, check the vehicle’s load limit, and choose the format that fits the cargo you carry most often.















