For a gothic makeup look, the right choice depends on whether you want a single defining product, an eye palette you can keep using, or a coordinated kit for a full dramatic face. I rank the DE’LANCI Red Black Goth Eyeshadow Palette first for its range of finishes, put the MEICOLY Gothic Black Makeup Kit ahead for a ready-to-go black eye-and-lip set, and recommend NYX Naughty Noir when black lipstick is the main goal. The tradeoff is clear: broader palettes offer more creative options, while kits and single products keep the look focused but leave less room to vary it.
Get your wardrobe favorites delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
These are individual product picks rather than five interchangeable cosmetics brands. I compare them by how well each supports gothic styling, how much variety it offers, and what a buyer gives up for that focus. A black-only kit may suit cosplay better than daily makeup; a multicolor palette can serve more looks but takes more choices—and sometimes more blending—to get right.
Key Takeaways
- Choose DE’LANCI‘s 15-shade palette for the widest range of gothic finishes, including matte, metallic, glitter, and multichrome.
- MEICOLY is the most direct all-in-one option here, pairing black shadow and liner with a black lip pencil and liquid lipstick.
- NYX Naughty Noir is the focused choice for buyers who already have eye products and want a vegan black matte lipstick.
- The six-color palette offers a mirror and a more edited gothic color story; DE’LANCI PANDA adds three more shades and a travel-friendly format.
- For everyday flexibility, the palettes with varied colors and finishes have an advantage over the black-only kit, which is geared toward dramatic or costume looks.
| DE’LANCI Red Black Goth Eyeshadow Palette, High Pigment, Vegan |  | Best Overall for Gothic Eye Looks | Shade count: 15 | Finishes: Matte, metallic, glitter, and multichrome | Style direction: Gothic, emo, cosplay, and dramatic looks | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| MEICOLY Gothic Black Makeup Kit |  | Best All-in-One Black Makeup Kit | Number of products: 4 | Included eye products: Matte black eyeshadow and liquid eyeliner | Included lip products: Black liquid lipstick and black lip pencil | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Black Smoky Eye Shadow Palette, DE’LANCI PANDA 9 Colors |  | Best Compact Smoky-Eye Palette | Shade count: 9 | Finishes: Matte and shimmer | Formula claim: Waterproof | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Lip Lingerie XXL Matte Liquid Lipstick – Naughty Noir (Black) |  | Best Black Lipstick | Product type: Liquid lipstick | Shade: Naughty Noir, black | Finish: Matte | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| 6-Color Goth Eyeshadow Palette with Matte and Shimmer Shades |  | Best Edited Gothic Color Story | Shade count: 6 | Shades: Dark grey, bright red, white, black, gold-to-white, and burgundy | Finishes: Matte and shimmer | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| goth makeup brand | Shade count | Finishes | Vegan |
|---|---|---|---|
| DE’LANCI Red Black Goth Eyesha | 15 | Matte, metallic, glitter, and multichrome | Yes |
| MEICOLY Gothic Black Makeup Ki | — | — | — |
| Black Smoky Eye Shadow Palette | 9 | Matte and shimmer | — |
| NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Lip Li | — | — | Yes |
| 6-Color Goth Eyeshadow Palette | 6 | Matte and shimmer | Yes |
More Details on Our Top Picks
DE’LANCI Red Black Goth Eyeshadow Palette, High Pigment, Vegan
I rank this first because its 15 shades and four finish types give it the broadest creative range in this lineup. Matte colors can anchor a smoky shape, while metallic, glitter, and multichrome options let a look move beyond a simple black eye. Compared with the DE’LANCI PANDA palette, this one is more oriented toward expressive, dramatic styling; compared with the six-color palette, it offers more room to build combinations rather than working from a tightly edited set.
That variety makes the palette the strongest pick for someone who wants gothic makeup to include more than one version of black shadow. The brand description also identifies it as vegan and cruelty-free, which may matter to buyers choosing products by those criteria. Its creative range has a learning curve, though: the supplied details say specific brushes or applicators may be needed for the best shimmer payoff. The dramatic color direction also makes it less useful for someone seeking a natural, low-effort daily palette. I would choose it for experimentation, not as the simplest entry point.
Pros:- 15 shades give more combinations than either smaller palette in this lineup.
- Matte, metallic, glitter, and multichrome finishes support varied dramatic looks.
- Described as vegan and cruelty-free.
- Compact design is suited to travel and on-the-go use.
Cons:- The dramatic selection is less suited to natural everyday makeup.
- Shimmer payoff may call for specific brushes or applicators.
Best for: Goth makeup fans who want multiple dramatic eye looks and value a palette with matte, metallic, glitter, and multichrome finishes.
Not ideal for: Buyers who want natural everyday shades, a minimal makeup routine, or shimmer that does not call for suitable brushes or applicators.
- Shade count:15
- Finishes:Matte, metallic, glitter, and multichrome
- Style direction:Gothic, emo, cosplay, and dramatic looks
- Vegan:Yes
- Cruelty-free:Yes
- Format:Compact
Our verdict“I would choose this palette for the widest range of creative gothic eye looks, provided I was comfortable working with vivid shades and multiple finishes.”
MEICOLY Gothic Black Makeup Kit
Where the DE’LANCI palette is about building different eye combinations, MEICOLY covers eyes and lips in one kit. It includes matte black eyeshadow, liquid eyeliner, a black lip pencil, and liquid lipstick, so it is the most direct choice here for a coordinated black gothic look without piecing together separate eye and lip products. That makes it especially relevant for costume makeup, theater, and cosplay, the uses named in its product information.
The focus is also its main limitation. Every included item centers on black, so this kit cannot offer the color variety of either multi-shade palette, and it is less flexible for buyers who want soft or everyday looks. Its formulas are described as waterproof, smudge-proof, and sweat-resistant; those claims may appeal for performance or event makeup, but the information does not establish how they wear for every person. I would rank it above a single lipstick for a full black look, but below the broad DE’LANCI palette for creative eye variety.
Pros:- Includes four products spanning eyes and lips.
- Matte black shadow is described as blendable.
- Formulas are described as waterproof, smudge-proof, and sweat-resistant.
- Purpose-built for dramatic gothic, costume, cosplay, and theater looks.
Cons:- The kit is limited to black makeup shades.
- Its dramatic, costume-oriented focus is less versatile for everyday wear.
Best for: Cosplay, theater, Halloween, or gothic makeup buyers who want several coordinating black eye and lip products in one set.
Not ideal for: Anyone looking for everyday color variety, softer looks, or a palette that can shift between several color stories.
- Number of products:4
- Included eye products:Matte black eyeshadow and liquid eyeliner
- Included lip products:Black liquid lipstick and black lip pencil
- Eyeshadow finish:Matte
- Performance claims:Waterproof, smudge-proof, and sweat-resistant
- Intended use:Goth makeup, Halloween, cosplay, theater, and costume parties
Our verdict“I would pick MEICOLY over a standalone product when I want a coordinated black look across both eyes and lips, but not for broad color variety.”
Black Smoky Eye Shadow Palette, DE’LANCI PANDA 9 Colors
The DE’LANCI PANDA palette is the most compact eye-focused alternative to the larger 15-shade DE’LANCI palette. Its nine matte and shimmer shades are presented for smoky, goth, and everyday looks, which makes it a more restrained choice for someone who wants black-centered makeup without committing to a highly theatrical color story. The travel-friendly size also gives it a practical edge over a larger selection when portability is the priority.
Its balance is useful, but not unlimited. The description notes that the shade range may feel narrow to some buyers, so it cannot match the 15-shade palette for finish variety or the six-color palette’s specified red, white, and burgundy accents. Although the shadow is described as waterproof and highly pigmented, primer may help with blending, according to the product details. I would put this ahead of the more specialized palettes for someone who wants a compact smoky-eye option, but below the overall pick for expressive gothic looks with more finish choices.
Pros:- Nine shades offer more options than a single black shadow.
- Matte and shimmer finishes support different smoky-eye effects.
- Described as waterproof and long-lasting.
- Travel-friendly size suits a compact makeup bag.
Cons:- The shade selection may feel limited to some users.
- Primer may be needed for the best blending.
Best for: Travelers and buyers who want a compact palette for black-centered smoky, gothic, and occasional everyday eye looks.
Not ideal for: Shoppers seeking an expansive color story, highly varied finishes, or the coordinated lip products included in the MEICOLY kit.
- Shade count:9
- Finishes:Matte and shimmer
- Formula claim:Waterproof
- Pigmentation:Described as high
- Format:Travel-friendly
- Suggested use:Smoky, gothic, and everyday looks
Our verdict“I would choose this over the larger DE’LANCI palette for compact smoky-eye versatility, but not when maximum shade or finish variety matters most.”
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Lip Lingerie XXL Matte Liquid Lipstick – Naughty Noir (Black)
NYX Naughty Noir is the clear choice when the gothic look starts and ends with a black matte lip. Unlike MEICOLY’s set, it does not include liner, shadow, or eye makeup, so it is not a complete look in a box. That narrower scope can be an advantage for buyers who already own their preferred eye products and want to add one defining lip shade rather than buy another full kit.
The formula is described as vegan, cruelty-free, lightweight, transfer-proof, and wearable for up to 16 hours. Those are useful product claims, but dark lipstick also rewards a steady hand: the description notes that precise application may be needed for even coverage. The black shade may not suit every complexion or personal style, and repeated use may feel drying. Compared with either eye palette, this is a focused finishing product; compared with MEICOLY, it offers just the lip step. I rank it for lipstick-specific buyers, not as the most complete answer to a broader search for gothic makeup.
Pros:- Black matte shade gives a strong gothic lip option.
- Described as vegan and cruelty-free.
- Formula is described as lightweight and transfer-proof.
- Product information claims wear of up to 16 hours.
Cons:- Dark shade may not suit every wearer or complexion.
- Precise application may be needed for even coverage.
- Frequent or excessive use may feel drying.
Best for: Buyers who want a standalone black matte liquid lipstick and already have their preferred eye makeup.
Not ideal for: Anyone seeking a coordinated eye-and-lip set, a subtle lip color, or a formula they can apply without precision.
- Product type:Liquid lipstick
- Shade:Naughty Noir, black
- Finish:Matte
- Vegan:Yes
- Cruelty-free:Yes
- Wear claim:Up to 16 hours
- Other formula claims:Lightweight and transfer-proof
Our verdict“I would choose NYX Naughty Noir for a focused black lip, while buyers who need matching eye products should choose MEICOLY instead.”
6-Color Goth Eyeshadow Palette with Matte and Shimmer Shades
This six-shade palette is the most deliberately edited choice in the lineup. Its specified colors—dark grey, red, white, black, gold-to-white, and burgundy—give it a distinctive gothic and costume direction without asking the buyer to sort through 15 shades. A mirror is included, which separates it from the other palette descriptions and may make application away from home more convenient. Compared with DE’LANCI PANDA, its color story is more explicitly spelled out; compared with the larger DE’LANCI palette, it offers fewer combinations and fewer listed finish types.
The product is described as vegan, not tested on animals, waterproof, and long-wearing, with a blendable, buildable formula. Those claims suit bold eye makeup, but the selection is not especially subtle, so it is a less adaptable pick for natural daily looks than a palette described for both gothic and everyday use. No applicator is mentioned, a practical detail to note if you expect one in the compact. I place it below the broader palettes because six shades limit experimentation, but it may be the better match for a buyer who wants this particular gothic color mix and a built-in mirror.
Pros:- Six shades create a clearly defined gothic color story.
- Includes matte and shimmer finishes with buildable color.
- Portable palette includes a mirror.
- Described as vegan and not tested on animals.
Cons:- Dark, bold colors may not suit subtle daily makeup.
- No applicator is listed among the included items.
Best for: Goth makeup buyers who want a compact, specified mix of black, grey, burgundy, red, and pale accent shades with a mirror.
Not ideal for: Anyone looking for a subtle everyday palette, an applicator included in the set, or extensive shade and finish variety.
- Shade count:6
- Shades:Dark grey, bright red, white, black, gold-to-white, and burgundy
- Finishes:Matte and shimmer
- Formula claims:Blendable, waterproof, and long-wearing
- Vegan:Yes
- Included accessory:Mirror
- Added ingredients:Shea butter and vitamin E
Our verdict“I would pick this for its specific gothic colors and mirror, but choose one of the larger palettes for more room to experiment.”
How We Picked
I judged each pick by its usefulness for gothic makeup, not by treating every black or dark cosmetic as a complete goth brand. I looked at what is included, how many looks the color selection can support, and whether the product seems geared toward everyday wear, dramatic styling, or cosplay. The supplied descriptions and specifications inform these comparisons; I do not present them as personal wear tests.
Ranking reflects the different jobs these products do. A palette with multiple finishes can build more eye looks than a single black shadow, so I give breadth weight when choosing an overall pick. The MEICOLY kit earns a distinct place because it covers both eyes and lips, while the NYX lipstick ranks as a focused lip option rather than a whole-face solution. I also weigh practical tradeoffs: portability, the need for careful application or blending, and whether the narrow color range suits a buyer’s intended use. Descriptions such as waterproof or long-wearing are reported as product claims, not guarantees for every wearer.
| goth makeup brand | Finishes |
|---|---|
| DE’LANCI Red Black Goth Eyesha | Matte, metallic, glitter, and multichrome |
| MEICOLY Gothic Black Makeup Ki | — |
| Black Smoky Eye Shadow Palette | Matte and shimmer |
| NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Lip Li | — |
| 6-Color Goth Eyeshadow Palette | Matte and shimmer |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Goth Makeup Brands
I would choose by the part of a gothic look that matters most to me: eyes, lips, or a coordinated set. That decision separates these five options more clearly than treating them as competing versions of the same product.
Decide whether you want a kit or one standout product
If I want black makeup for both eyes and lips without assembling separate products, MEICOLY is the direct option: its four pieces cover shadow, liner, lip pencil, and liquid lipstick. If I already have eye makeup, NYX Naughty Noir makes more sense as a single black lipstick. Neither replaces the flexibility of a palette, and the NYX product is a lip-only choice. I would start with the part of my routine I actually need to add, rather than buying a full set just because it sounds more complete.
Match palette size to the looks you want
The 15-shade DE’LANCI palette is the broadest creative option, particularly for buyers who want to mix matte, metallic, glitter, and multichrome effects. DE’LANCI PANDA is the more compact black-centered palette, while the six-color option is the most tightly defined selection. More shades can support experimentation, but they also mean more choices; an edited palette may be easier to use when you have a clear color story in mind. I would not assume that a higher shade count automatically makes a palette better for my routine.
Think about gothic wear beyond costume events
For theatrical, cosplay, or costume makeup, MEICOLY’s coordinated black products are particularly aligned with the stated use. For gothic eye looks with more color and finish variation, the DE’LANCI 15-shade palette offers the strongest spread. DE’LANCI PANDA is described for both gothic and everyday looks, making it the more adaptable option on paper. The six-shade palette and black lipstick can still work for personal style, but their bold colors may be less suitable if I want a very subtle daily finish.
Treat performance claims as claims, not a personal guarantee
Several descriptions mention waterproof, long-wearing, transfer-proof, or smudge-resistant performance. Those statements may help narrow options for events, but they do not tell me exactly how a formula will behave on my skin, lips, or preferred application method. I would also account for the practical notes provided: NYX may need precise lip application, the 15-shade palette may need suitable applicators for shimmer, and the PANDA palette may blend best with primer. Those requirements can matter as much as the finish itself.
Check the limitations of a dark color story
Black and saturated shades are central to these picks, but they do not suit every style or every occasion. MEICOLY is limited to black products, while the palettes remain weighted toward smoky and dramatic looks even when they add accent colors. If I need a palette that can move easily between natural neutrals and gothic color, none of these descriptions promises a broad neutral range. I would choose the narrowness deliberately: it is a strength for a focused look and a drawback when versatility is the priority.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which pick is the best starting point for gothic makeup?
I would start with the DE’LANCI Red Black palette if I want several ways to create dramatic gothic eye looks, since its 15 shades cover matte, metallic, glitter, and multichrome finishes. For a first coordinated black look across eyes and lips, MEICOLY is a more direct set, but its black-only selection gives me less room to vary the color story.
Which option includes both eye and lip products?
The MEICOLY Gothic Black Makeup Kit is the only option here described as covering both eyes and lips. It includes black eyeshadow, liquid eyeliner, a black lip pencil, and liquid lipstick. The NYX product is only a liquid lipstick, and the three other picks are eyeshadow palettes.
Which palette offers the most variety?
The DE’LANCI Red Black palette has the largest listed selection at 15 shades and includes matte, metallic, glitter, and multichrome finishes. That makes it the broadest palette for creative gothic looks in this group. It is also the most dramatic option, so I would not choose it expecting a mostly natural collection of shades.
Is there a good choice for a compact makeup bag?
DE’LANCI PANDA is described as travel-friendly and focuses on nine smoky, goth, and everyday shades. The six-color palette is also portable and has a mirror, while the 15-shade DE’LANCI palette is described as compact. I would pick PANDA for a specifically black-centered eye palette or the six-color option if an included mirror matters more.
Are these products suitable for everyday wear?
That depends on how bold I want my daily makeup to be. DE’LANCI PANDA is explicitly described for gothic and everyday looks, while the MEICOLY kit is framed mainly for dramatic or costume use. The black lipstick and other palettes can be worn outside events, but their dark shades and dramatic focus make them less adaptable for a subtle look.
Conclusion
For the widest range of gothic eye looks, I recommend the DE’LANCI 15-shade palette; for a coordinated black look across eyes and lips, I would choose MEICOLY. Buyers who only need a black lip can keep the decision focused with NYX Naughty Noir. I would select DE’LANCI PANDA for a compact smoky-eye palette and the six-color palette for its specified gothic color story and mirror. The best pick is the one that fits the part of my routine I want to build, since these options range from single-purpose lipstick to palettes and a full black makeup kit.
