Skip to Content

Top 10 Witchy Makeup Brands

The art of makeup is a skill that takes time and practice to acquire. The creativity is endless. The art of witchy makeup has the power to make you feel magical, with beautifully dark power. Knowing the right brand when you are going to give yourself a witchy look for everyday use or just for an event will make you feel confident in your own skin.

The Following are the top witchy makeup brands, we could find.

Witchy Makeup Brands

Top Witchy Makeup Brands 

1.Rituel De Fille

This brand was created by three sisters who are invested in the magical and witchy makeup vibes. Each of their products is created by themselves and they compare the making of each one to potion making.

They emphasize using the smallest amount of ingredients possible and attention to detail when creating products. The three sisters are also committed and Leaping Bunny Certified to being cruelty free. Their products will never be tested on animals.

Their brand may be on the more expensive side if you plan to buy multiple products to complete your witchy look. From Color Nectar Lip Balm called Bloodflower that starts at $24 to their Ash and Ember Eye Soot called Cultist at $38 it adds up quickly. However, they do offer free shipping over a certain amount of money spent along with a 10% off first purchase. A good brand comes at a more expensive price tag, but if you’re invested in the witchy makeup arts this brand could be great for you.


  • Uses small amount of ingredients
  • Great reviews
  • Free shipping over certain amount spent
  • Doesn’t test on animals
  • Founders are into the magical witchy vibes


Can get pricey, but not as expensive as others

2.Aquarian Soul

This brand is women owned and based out of San Diego, California. They believe that their combination of plant medicine with crystal energies allow for a better wellbeing. Their ingredients are 100% plant based and organic. Their packaging is also ecofriendly and can be recycled. They too are committed to never testing on animals.

Although, Aquarian Soul is more focused on serums, oils, and body butters. They have an emphasis on skin care and wellbeing but do offer witchy makeup options. For example, they carry various lip balms and highlights in colors that will add to a witchy look. Their price range is slightly cheaper than that of Rituel De Fille but too can add up quickly when getting multiple items.


  • Ecofriendly
  • Natural Ingredients
  • Not testing on animals


  • Main focus is not makeup
  • Witchy vibes, but no dark witchy makeup

3.Lunatick Cosmetic Labs

This brand was created by industry professionals in 2012 and work in making vegan and cruelty free cosmetics. Creating witchy makeup is their main focus. The products come in witchy packaging as well. Such as their Zombie Defense palate that comes in the shape of a coffin. It appears that they have more lip products out of anything, from lip dies, lipstick, and lip slick.

Their products do not come with a lot of description of what is or what it was created for. It states the colors and does give a complete list of the ingredients that go into the particular product. Being a newer brand, there are not many reviews but even so there are a lot of positive ones. The price is also quite cheap. Most products from this brand range in the $10 area.



  • Cheap
  • Doesn’t test on animals
  • Lists all ingredients
  • 100% vegan


  • Small descriptions of products
  • Have to spend $130+ for free shipping

4.Urban Decay

Created in Southern California in 1996, this witchy makeup brand believes makeup is to show who you are and is cruelty free along with making vegan options. This brand is one of the more well-established witchy makeup brands. Its website features a virtual try on, tutorials, and a shade finder. They offer members only perks and their own online offers. Their products are accompanied with tips and explanations of what they are and why they are great.

There is a large number of witchy makeup products on their website along with products for those who are not into the witchy look. The prices of most products appear to be on the more expensive side, but they do offer cheaper options as low as $7. The more expensive options usually come with multiple items.


  • Vegan Options
  • Virtual try on
  • Well established brand
  • Cheaper options


  • Can get expensive
  • Not solely focused on witchy makeup


Aromaleigh is independently owned by one woman who makes makeup based out in South Carolina but was originally founded in New York in 1998. Aromaeigh’s products are created in small batches and every product is filled or sample is filled by hand.

There are vegan friendly options and products are never tested on animals. The founder offers to be sent a message if there are any questions about ingredients within the products as well.

There is a countless number of products on the website. The most witchy makeup products can be found by going to the shop by collection area. Although this brand is not exclusively witchy. There are a ton of witchy makeup colors to go through. This brand is also extremely cheap. There are eye shadows that start in the $2 range. Each collection has a story behind it and offers colors specifically to the picture or story shown.


  • Very cheap
  • Vegan options
  • Countless colors


  • Website feels cluttered
  • Witchy options, but not solely focused on a witchy vibe


6.My Pretty Zombie (MPZ) Cosmetics

This is a newer brand that started in 2010 on Etsy and established a website in 2013. There is a brand with a similar name to this one that the owner does not have affiliation with. This brand gives off a very edgy witchy vibe. Since it appears to be an at home business the website itself is very different than that of a large company’s website.

The most useful place to understand this brand completely is in the FAQ section that explains shipping and number of products that has to be bought in order to receive a tracking number. The brand offers 2 large sales a year and the products are fairly cheap. Ranging in the $8-$20 area for most. MPZ offers a large number of witchy colors and products that may suit you.


  • Vegan options
  • Cheap
  • Large number of color options
  • FAQ section has a lot of detail


  • Must buy 12 samples in order to get a tracking number
  • No free shipping
  • Some product photos are not extremely clear


7.Melt Cosmetics

Melt Cosmetics was created in 2012 by Lora Arellano and Dana Bomar. When they first created the brand, they wanted to create rich and bold colors that they felt the world was missing. This brand does all sort of witchy makeup from lipstick to gel liner. The website and packaging on the products are very witchy. Like others, they offer vegan options, never test on animals, and give a full list of ingredients.

Their products range within the $20 are but can be more expensive if you were to buy a collection such as their Amor Y Mariposas Collection which is around $425. They do offer priority shipping on purchased above $75 and domestic to international shipping. Reviews for this brand are very high on their website but can vary around 3.8-4.5 out of 5 depending on where you look.


  • Bold colors
  • Less expensive options
  • Vegan options
  • No testing on animals
  • Ingredient list


  • Can get expensive

8.Manic Panic

Located in New York, NY this brand was created by sisters Tish and Snooky Bellomo. Although this brand labels itself more of a punk rock type of brand, their colors and products can be used for your witchy look. Along with being vegan and cruelty free they offer other products than just makeup such as hair dye that can contribute to your witchy look. They also state that their hair dye has been used by big name celebrities.

The brands makeup packaging gives off a very witchy look. For example, their Apparition Cross Gloss is packaged with a black cross on top of the lid and their Raven Black Crème Makeup has witchy font and a raven on it.

This brand offers sales throughout the year and has generally decent prices that can be cheaper or more expensive. Although they do carry a lot of witchy makeup products it appears that a lot are sold out and that getting your hands on a certain color could end up being challenging.


  • Products used by celebrities
  • Cheaper options
  • Witchy colors


  • May be out of stock
  • Can get pricey quickly


9.Black Moon Cosmetics

Established in 2015, Black Moon is one of the newer, very witchy cosmetic brands out there. Their leading focus is on lips and eyes but do have other witchy makeup options. There lipstick has an enormous number of colors to choose from. Their eye dust and palates may not have as many color options as their lipstick but come in witchy colors.

What is different about this brand is that they feature a lipstick called warrior and all sales of that lipstick are donated to cancer treatment and research. Most of their makeup products start around the $18 and go up from there.


  • Donates to cancer research
  • Vegan options
  • No animal cruelty


  • Can get expensive

10.Necromancy Cosmetica

The creators of this brand, Des and Zal, have created a brand that is truly in touch with the darker side. Both creators work in Puerto Rico and hand craft the products themselves. They even have a store front in Puerto Rico. Their central focus is non liquid lipstick that come in witchy, gothic colors.

Their lipsticks start at $16, and they only offer one eye shadow palette for $42. This brand is in the cheaper range and does give a list of ingredients with their products. Like all the other witchy makeup brands they too believe in being and are cruelty free.


  • Hand crafted
  • Cheaper
  • Witchy colors
  • No testing on animals


  • Mainly lipstick

How To Choose The Best Witchy Make Up Brand?

A few steps that should be taken before deciding on which brand is best for you is considering your skin type, ingredients in the makeup, and reviews. These will help you find the best witchy makeup brand for you.

Skin Type

Your skin type and knowing what your skin reacts to is important when considering a witchy make up brand. If you have dry or oily skin, you will most likely want something that does not add to those. Powdery makeup products could combat oily skin along with blotting papers.

Those with dryer skin types may want to try a product that leaves more of a dewy look. Witchy makeup, along with your average makeup could affect your acne. Knowing how your skin reacts to certain ingredients will help you with possible breakouts.


There are certain ingredients that dermatologists and other doctors say are ingredients that can cause acne for some people but my not cause acne for others. This does not mean you will breakout, it is just possible. When choosing your witchy makeup, trial and error of certain brands may be the best way for you to find out what ingredients work with your skin.


Reviewing reviews will always be helpful when picking which witchy makeup brand is right for you. From looking through Amazon to reading the comments in a brands Instagram profile. These can be helpful to see how others feel about the company and their products. Reading through reviews will tell you if they are legit, slow or fast at shipping, have good customer service or not, are priced fairly, or are using good ingredients.


There are many witchy makeup brands out there for you to choose from. The best way to figure out which brand is right for you is to consider your skin type, price range, the ingredients, and to see what others are saying about them. When it comes down to choosing a witchy makeup brand, trial and error may also come in handy.

Related Guides