10 Best Butterscotch Candy Brands

With origins dating back to the beginning of the 19th century, butterscotch is a popular candy and ice cream flavor. Butterscotch’s main ingredients include brown sugar, butter, cream, and corn syrup. If you’re a fan of butterscotch, you can choose from tons of brands that sell high-quality and delicious butterscotch flavored candies.

We reviewed some of the most popular butterscotch candy brands available worldwide. Some of the best brands include Brach’s Candy, Reed’s Candy, and See’s Candies. A handful of other brands make irresistible butterscotch treats, such as Russell Stover and Al Simpkin. 

Best Butterscotch Candy Brands

Do you love butterscotch as much as we do? Check out the top 10 butterscotch candy brands.

Top Butterscotch Candy Brands

1.Brach’s Candy

Based out of Illinois, Brach’s Candy is a household name that sells hard candies, chocolates, and jelly beans. You can find Brach’s products at virtually any supermarket and convenience store. Brach’s sells hard butterscotch candy in two-pound packages.

Made with 100% real butter, these candies are some of the bests on the market. You’ll enjoy their bold flavor that’s not overpowered by sweetness.

While various knockoffs try to replicate Brach’s signature butterscotch candy, you won’t find the same premium taste anywhere else. These candies also have a little bit of salt that makes them so much more irresistible. If you’re trying to cut back on sugar, there’s also a sugar-free option made with Splenda. 

The ingredients in Brach’s butterscotch candies are simple, and perhaps that’s why they’re such a fan favorite.

The main ingredients include corn syrup, sugar, butter, salt, and a combination of acritical and natural flavors. Each candy comes individually wrapped. Butterscotch fanatics love these candies for their “great flavor” and affordable price.  

2.Reed’s Candy

The next butterscotch candy brand to make our list is Reed’s Candy. This confectionery company has a long history in the United States, with roots dating back to 1893. Reed’s Candy created butterscotch candy as its first product.

They later made cinnamon, root beer, wintergreen, peppermint, spearmint, and caramel rum candies. Today, you can still buy the brand’s butterscotch, cinnamon, root beer, and peppermint flavors in a pocket-size roll of 12 candies and 4-ounce backs.

While you won’t find Reed’s Candy in every supermarket and convenience store, you can find the brand online and in novelty candy stores. Reed’s makes its butterscotch candy in small batches, still using its old-fashioned methods.

The brand slowly stirs its secret formula to ensure that there are no bubbles in the candy. These smooth, hard candies quickly melt in your mouth.

When it comes to ingredients, Reed’s Candy keeps it simple. Its Butterscotch Old-Fashioned Hard Candy contains sugar, glucose, butter, salt, and syrup.

There are no artificial ingredients like you find in many candies on the store shelves today. When you suck on Reed’s butterscotch hard candy, you can enjoy the same delectable flavors of the late 19th century.

3.See’s Candies

If you’ve been to the mall around the holidays, you’ve probably seen a See’s Candies kiosk handing out samples. When it comes to butterscotch candy, See’s Candies offers a wide selection of products.

Some of the brand’s most popular butterscotch treats include its Butterscotch Lollypops, caramel Butterscotch Chew, and Milk Butterscotch Squares. If you buy the lollipops from See’s Candies’ website, you’ll get about 30 per box.

See’s Candies has been around since 1921 and continues to use its old-fashioned ways to produce its mouthwatering treats. The Butterscotch Lollypops, for example, contain corn syrup, sugar, milk, brown sugar, vinegar, and salt.

These are essentially the only ingredients needed to make caramel and butterscotch. Although See’s Candies’ products come at a premium price, you won’t find any artificial ingredients in their goodies. 

4.AL Simpkin

Earning the fourth spot on our list is AL Simpkin, a family-owned confectionery company from Sheffield, United Kingdom. AL Simpkins is famous for the small tins used to package its products, known as the “Travel Tin Collection.”

This collection includes butterscotch-flavored hard candies. You’ll also find chocolate mint, chocolate strawberry, and raspberry, and tropical fruit drops, to name a few.

Although this brand is from the United Kingdom, you can still find its iconic products throughout North America and mainland Europe.

The butterscotch flavored travel sweets come in a seven-ounce tin and boast only natural colors and flavors – nothing artificial. Furthermore, these butterscotch candies are dairy and gluten-free, and the main ingredients include sugar, glucose syrup, and natural flavors.  

5.Dr. John’s Healthy Sweets

Dr. John’s is a bit unique because compared to the other brands on our list, all Dr. John’s candies contain natural sweeteners that are tooth-friendly. Suppose you have kids with a history of cavities; this is an excellent brand of sweets to give them. This brand sells old-fashioned Butterscotch Hard Candies. You can choose from three different sizes – 24 pieces, 100 pieces, and 250 pieces.

If you want to indulge and eat a handful of Dr. John’s Butterscotch Hard Candies, there are a handful of benefits. Each serving has 10 grams of fiber, and the candies are sugar-free.

To sweeten the candy, Dr. John’s uses xylitol and erythritol, two plant-based sweeteners. These are also a great option if you have any allergies.

The brand makes its Butterscotch Hard Candies in a nut-free facility, and they contain no dairy, soy, eggs, or gluten. Not only are these candies low in calories, but they’re also an excellent choice for people with diabetes. 

6.Cavendish & Harvey

Cavendish & Harvey is similar to AL Simpkin in that it sells its hard candies in a small tin. You can find its products at Walmart and various other retail stores and e-commerce websites, such as Amazon.

Based out of Germany, this confectionary makes heavenly Creamy Butterscotch Drops that come in a six-ounce tin. The brand also sells various other hard candies in tins, including Sour Lemon, Juice Apple, and Pink Grapefruit Drops.

Perhaps the best part of Cavendish & Harvey’s Creamy Butterscotch Drops is that they come dusted with sweet icing sugar.

Like most of the brands on our list, Cavendish & Harvey makes these tasty candies with real butter and milk. Moreover, there are no preservatives or artificial coloring. The main ingredients include glucose syrup, sugar, sweetened condensed whole milk, and pure 5% butterfat. 

7.Life Savers

Owned by Mars, Incorporated, Life Savers is a famous brand of hard candies found in the United States and worldwide. Since the brand’s inception in 1912, over 40 flavors have hit the market, including Butter Rum – the brand’s butterscotch version.

You can find this popular product in big-name grocery stores, gas stations, and on Amazon. While these hard candies typically come in rolled single packs, you can also buy mixed packs that include other flavors. 

The main ingredients in Live Savers’ Butter Rum Hard Candy include sugar, corn syrup, high fructose corn syrup, and molasses. Although this is a great-tasting, affordable product, it’s a bit lower on our list because it contains artificial ingredients and caramel coloring.

Nonetheless, Life Savers can ‘save’ the day if you’re looking for a quick butterscotch fix and don’t have time to visit a specialty candy store or shop online. 

8.Russell Stover

Russell Stover might be of America’s most famous candy companies. Founded in 1923, Russell Stover sells an expansive collection of boxed chocolates, caramels, and hard candies.

You can find Russell Stover products in virtually any grocery store, online, and in Russell Stover’s retail stores. When it comes to butterscotch, Russell Stover sells a 12-ounce bag of Butterscotch Buttons. 

Even though Russell Stover calls these ‘Butterscotch Buttons,’ they don’t have butter, making them an excellent treat for lactose-intolerant people.

Russell Stover makes these candies with sugar, corn syrup, salt, and a combination of artificial flavors and colors. Despite the artificial flavors, many reviewers note that these candies do not have an artificial taste.

9.Fifty 50

Based out of Rochester, New York, Fifty 50 is a brand that specializes in making snacks with low glycemic levels. One of the company’s snacks is its sugar-free and certified-Kosher Certified Butterscotch Hard Candy. Fifty 50 sells these tasty candies on Amazon, iHerb, and various local grocery stores.

Fifty 50 makes their Butterscotch Hard Candy with polyglycitol syrup, salt, isomalt (a sugar substitute), and artificial and natural flavors. We placed Fifty 50 a little low on our list because, unfortunately, they manufacture their candies on the same equipment that processes various allergens. 

10.Dum Dums

The last brand on our list is the iconic Dum Dums. Created in 1924, Dum Dums are suckers that come in various flavors – butterscotch, cherry, cotton candy, and cream soda, to name a few. Of course, the butterscotch flavor might be one of the most popular.

You can buy packages of just the butterscotch flavor on various websites, such as Amazon and Spangler Candy.

The common ingredients in Dum Dums include sugar, corn syrup, citric acid, and various acritical flavors and colors. Unfortunately, you won’t find natural butter or milk like some other brands on our list. 


No matter which brand you choose from our list, we’re confident that you’ll enjoy every last taste of the rich butterscotch flavor.

These brands have a long history of creating high-quality and consistent butterscotch candies that millions of consumers enjoy. Enjoy either natural butterscotch flavor or artificial flavor that gives off a genuine taste.