7 Best Black Walnut Ice Cream Brands

Black walnut ice cream is known for being delicious. However, you may be wondering which brand to buy based on a few factors, such as nutrition and price. Some may not be as expensive and taste great.

Others you have to eat at home as opposed to a dining experience. You’ll want to get the ice cream that’s best for you.

Never worry again about missing out on the best black walnut ice cream available. With the assistance of this list, you’ll find the best. All ice cream is sought after but here are some black walnut ice cream brands you should try.  

Here is a quick breakdown of our favorite black walnut ice cream brands and their defining features. 

  • Baskin-Robbins– Best Dining Experience
  • Mayfield– Best Southern Brand
  • Signature SELECT– Best Luxury Brand
  • Bluebell– Best Readily Available Brand
  • Hiland– Best Value Brand
  • Turner– Best Calorie Count Brand
  • Blue Bunny– Most Affordable Brand

These are our top picks for black walnut ice cream brands. There are a lot of details to cover here, so we put together this article on the top black walnut ice cream brands. We will cover expensive and affordable consumer ice cream brands, as well as some ice cream ingredients. 

Black Walnut Ice Cream

Top Black Walnut Ice Cream Brands

1.Baskin-Robbins– Best Dining Experience

You can buy a single scoop of black walnut ice cream for $2.79. It’s a black walnut explosion. Nothing could stop this full flavor from being so satisfying to adults and children alike. The first ingredient in this ice cream is cream, followed by skim milk and sugar.

It contains real black walnut. This is the only ice cream on this list where you can dine out to have it! You might want to take a special someone to go try this black walnut ice cream. You certainly won’t regret it.


  • Excellent taste
  • Wide availability


  • Pricey

2.Mayfield– Best Southern Brand

You can buy this black walnut ice cream in a 1.5-quart container. It is made with wild-grown black walnut. This is great ice cream if you are trying to change things up. They are made available throughout eight Southeastern states.

It is made in the South. You can call your local store to confirm availability. The first ingredients of this ice cream are buttermilk, cream, and sugar.

There are 190 calories in ⅔ cups. This is great-tasting ice cream with a good ingredient list that should satisfy your craving for black walnut ice cream. You should check out your local store today if you live in the South as this is a taste you shouldn’t pass up on. 


  • High-quality
  • Esteemed Southern brand


  • Expensive
  • High calorie

3.Signature SELECT– Best Luxury Brand

Signature SELECT black walnut ice cream is $4.99 for 1.50 quarts. It has real black walnut pieces. It is 200 calories per ⅔ cup. It is 100% guaranteed or your money back. The first ingredients are milk, cream, and sugar.

This is a decadent ice cream that is worth the money with excellent ingredients. You’ll want to pick some out at your local store today so you can try it. It’s one of the best ice creams on this list by far. 


  • Great luxurious taste


  • Relatively limited selection

4.Bluebell– Best Readily Available Brand

You can get Bluebell black walnut ice cream for $8.97 for 0.5 gals. It combines the taste of walnut and cream. It is 230 calories per ⅔ cup.

It tastes excellent and is a fan favorite. You’ll want to try this brand out as it’s available nationwide. You get the most bang for your buck here and there’s a good ingredient list. The calorie count is a bit high but that’s okay if you are treating yourself. 


  • Affordable
  • Readily available


  • Limited materials selection
  • High calorie


5.Hiland– Best Value Brand

Hiland Black Walnut Ice Cream is our best value brand choice. It tastes excellent whether you are a child or an adult.

The first ingredients are milkfat and nonfat milk, sugar, and black walnuts. This is an excellent tasting ice cream and the best value brand we selected. You’ll want to go to your local grocery store to pick some up. It would go great as your dessert with dinner tonight. Trust us you’ll enjoy every bite!


  • Excellent taste. 
  • Best value


  • Ingredient list

6.Turner– Best Calorie Count Brand

Turner black walnut ice cream is our best calorie count brand at 170 calories per 0.5 cup. Quality and freshness have been a Turner tradition for over eighty years. They offer a 100% guarantee. The first ingredients are milkfat and nonfat milk, sugar, and black walnut.

With an ingredient list like that, how could you pass this one up? You’ll have to go to the grocery store nearest you to purchase this ice cream so you can try it.

It would go great in a refreshing sundae you make at home. There’s nothing better than black walnut ice cream with a cherry on top. 


  • Classic
  • Wide selection 
  • Guaranteed


  • Ingredients

7.Blue Bunny– Most Affordable Brand

Blue Bunny black walnut ice cream is our most affordable brand. It is made with milk, skim milk, and cream as the first ingredients. It contains English walnuts. It tastes excellent and is a fan favorite.

This ice cream is very affordable and has an excellent taste to boot! You’ll want to get it quickly as there is limited availability. You’ll need to call your local store to make sure they have it in stock. If they do, this is a great treat on a warm day. Nothing better than black walnut ice cream in the Summer!


  • Very affordable
  • Excellent taste


  • Limited availability 

Tips for Buying Black Walnut Ice Cream

  • Decide if you want an experience out or if you don’t mind eating it at home. You might enjoy a visit to a Baskin-Robbins location or perhaps a local ice cream shop. 
  • Consider price, don’t pay too much for black walnut ice cream. Most black walnut ice cream is very affordable, so you won’t have to miss out on your favorite brand. 
  • See what is available in your area before you make a decision. Some stores will carry different brands. Compare ingredients before you buy. 
  • Consider the first ingredients on the package. Is it milk or cream? This would be the best-case scenario. 
  • Does it have a 100% guarantee if you don’t like it? You’ll want to consider getting your monkey back if you don’t like the ice cream you purchased. 
  • Is it on sale? If so you’ll want to catch it right away before it sells out. 

Does black walnut ice cream ever go on sale? 

Yes! While most black walnut ice cream is always affordable, it does sometimes go on sale. You’ll want to get to the store to purchase it quickly before it sells out and you miss out on its great taste. 

Is black walnut ice cream vegan? 

No, unfortunately, none of the ice cream brands we covered are vegan. Perhaps there will be vegan black walnut ice cream in the future, or perhaps you could even make your own!

Is black walnut ice cream low fat? 

No, unfortunately non of the ice cream brands we covered are low fat, however, some have lower calorie counts than others. If you are on a diet you may want black walnut ice cream on a cheat day, just pay attention to nutrition facts and serving sizes. You may want to look at ingredients as well. 

Is black walnut ice cream seasonal?

During certain times of the year, it may be harder to find black walnut ice cream but you should be able to find it in the Summer months without issue. You can contact your local store and let them know you’d like them to carry it year-round. 

How do you know if your ice cream has genuine black walnut? 

You can find out if your ice cream has genuine black walnut simply by looking at the ingredients. You want to choose ice cream with the best most simple ingredients for health reasons. 


Black walnut ice cream is among the best flavors of ice cream in the world and is highly sought after by food enthusiasts. If you are thinking of buying a black walnut ice cream then any of these 7 brands would be a good choice.

We ranked Baskin-Robbins as the best overall dining experience, but the other brands are good for different purposes.

Black walnut ice cream makes Summertime fun and is great whether you are dining out or eating it at home. Try having black walnut ice cream as dessert after dinner or on the side of cake or pie. You’ll never regret this sweet decision out of any of the brands you could choose. 

Whatever your decisions, just make sure you do your research before buying black walnut ice cream. Take your time when deciding and choose carefully.